Top 10 Best Protein Powders of 2024
Here are the GOATED Top 10 Best Protein Powders of 2024 available on the market today ⬇️ Best High-Stimulant Pre-workout
Follow Us ⬇️
Product | Details | Goated Score |
|---|---|---|
#1 MuscleSport Fluffernutter Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
|  9.7/10 |
#2 Apollon Salty Peanuts Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
| 9.6/10 |
#3 Ryse Skippy Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
| 9.5/10 |
#4 Ryse Xmas Tree Cake Buy on @stoll.fit Tiktok Shop |
| 9.5/10 |
#5 Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter Pie Buy on @stoll.fit Tiktok Shop |
| 9.5/10 |
#6 MuscleSport Protella Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
| 9.4/10 |
#7 GHOST Caramel Pecan Cinnabon Buy on @stoll.fit Tiktok Shop |
| 9.3/10 |
#8 Panda Sundae Cone Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
| 9.3/10 |
#9 Panda S'mores Use Code Stoll to save 15% |
| 9.3/10 |
#10 Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter N' Honey Buy on @stoll.fit Tiktok Shop |
| 9.2/10 |
What to Look for in a Top-Tier Protein Powder
- Taste is KING!
- If it doesn’t taste amazing, it’s automatically out.
- It’s 2024—there’s no excuse for bad-tasting protein. A solid protein powder should taste like a dessert you look forward to daily.
- Smooth, Effortless Texture
- No clumps, no grittiness—just smooth mixing, even in water.
- Typically, thicker protein shakes are more desirable, but there are a few exceptions.
- High-Quality Ingredients
- Whey protein should be the star of the show (whey concentrate, isolate, or hydrolysate).
- Clean ingredient profiles with no unnecessary fillers, artificial junk, or low-quality protein sources.
- Balanced Macros
- A strong protein-to-calorie ratio with low carbs and fats.
- Mixability
- Should blend effortlessly with a shaker or spoon leaving a consistent texture every time.
- The GOATED Standard
- While taste is prioritized, other factors like texture, inclusions (like digestive enzymes), and ingredients are still carefully considered.
This list dives into what makes each protein powder stand out and why it’s worth your attention!
#1 MuscleSport Fluffernutter Protein
9.7/10
MuscleSport Fluffernutter: The GOATED Protein Powder
When it comes to protein powders, MuscleSport’s Fluffernutter is in a league of its own—so much so that it holds the #1 ranked spot at GOATED. This flavor is exactly what you’d hope for from the name: a perfect balance of rich, nutty peanut butter and sweet, fluffy marshmallow, just like the classic sandwich. But what really sets it apart is the texture. Along with its smooth and creamy consistency, MuscleSport took it up a notch by adding mini marshmallow inclusions, giving it an almost hot cocoa-like vibe—except swap the chocolate for peanut butter and marshmallow. I’ve tried more protein powders than I can count, and this one is truly second to none. Best protein powders
Beyond its top-tier flavor, MuscleSport protein is as premium as it gets. While they’re already known for crafting some of the best-tasting protein on the market, the quality of their ingredients is just as impressive. Fluffernutter is made with whey isolate and hydrolysate, two of the cleanest and fastest-digesting protein sources available. But they didn’t stop there—they also included a fat-burning complex and an absorption matrix, making sure your body gets the most out of every scoop.
#2 Apollon Salty Peanuts Protein
9.6/10
Apollon Salty Peanuts: GOATED #2 Ranked Protein Powder
Coming in at #2 on GOATED’s rankings, Apollon’s Salty Peanut protein is an absolute staple. Apollon is best known for formulating some of the most loaded-to-the-gills pre-workouts in the industry, but what many don’t realize is that their protein is just as premium. I tried this back-to-back with MuscleSport’s Fluffernutter, and I genuinely couldn’t decide which was better. The only reason I gave the slight edge to MuscleSport was because I personally love inclusions in my protein. But if you’re just looking for the best straight-up peanut butter protein, Apollon’s Salty Peanut has you covered. It is the most true-to-self peanut butter protein I have ever tried. Bold, rich, and perfectly salty-sweet... truly a masterpiece.
One thing that immediately stood out is the texture. This is, in my opinion, the thickest protein powder I’ve ever tried, and that’s thanks to Apollon’s unique blend of whey isolate and casein. Casein is known for its thick, creamy consistency and exceptional mouthfeel, while whey isolate is one of the cleanest, fastest-digesting protein sources available—keeping things smooth while also reducing calories, fat, and lactose. If you’re searching for a straight-up peanut butter protein, this is going to be very tough to beat. The only one that even comes close is Ryse’s Skippy protein, which takes the #3 spot on GOATED’s list. But if texture and flavor are what you’re after, Apollon’s Salty Peanut is an absolute must-try.
#3 Ryse Skippy Protein
9.2/10
Ryse Skippy: Are You Seeing a Trend Here?
Coming in at #3 on GOATED’s rankings, Ryse Skippy Protein is nothing short of a legend in the industry. Ryse has exploded in popularity over the past few years, becoming one of the fastest-growing supplement companies on the planet—and for good reason. While they offer a stacked lineup of high-quality products, they’re best known for their ridiculously good-tasting protein powders, many of which are official collaborations with household names like Skippy (and trust me, this won’t be the last Ryse collab you see on this list). For the longest time, Skippy was my #1 ranked protein, period. And I’m not alone—countless others in the fitness space agree that this is one of the best-tasting protein powders in existence. The flavor accuracy is unreal, delivering a taste that’s nearly identical to a scoop of Skippy peanut butter straight from the jar but with 20g of protein.
In fact, if we’re talking straight-up peanut butter taste, Ryse Skippy and Apollon’s Salty Peanut are almost spitting images of one another. The only reason I had to give Apollon the edge is because their formula is thicker, thanks to their use of casein protein. That’s not to say Ryse isn’t thick—because Ryse actually makes some of the thickest protein powders in the industry—but it’s just hard to compete with casein. Still, Skippy is an absolute must-try, and thousands of protein lovers would agree.
#4 Ryse Xmas Tree Cake Protein
9.1/10
Ryse Xmas Tree Cake: Another Banger!
Coming in at #4 on GOATED’s rankings, Ryse Xmas Tree Cake protein is another banger from the Ryse team. Remember when I said Skippy wouldn’t be the last Ryse collab on this list? Well, here it is. This protein actually dropped by accident in October 2024 when Vitamin Shoppe mistakenly listed it early on their website. They quickly took it down, but by then, the word was already out. I was lucky enough to get my hands on it early, and let me tell you—this one delivers. It’s got a smooth and creamy white cake batter base with a light vanilla undertone that makes it as delicious as it gets. On top of that, it includes holiday glitter pieces that add just the right amount of texture.
Like most Ryse proteins, the texture is thick and has an exceptional mouthfeel, making every sip feel indulgent. But what really sets this one apart is how spot-on it is to an actual Little Debbie Xmas Tree Cake. It’s sweet, smooth, and nostalgic in all the right ways. Ryse did say this was a limited edition drop, but honestly, I’m hoping they bring it back—because it’s way too good to be a one-time thing. Notice this is the first protein on this list that is not peanut butter flavored...
#5 Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter Pie Protein
9.0/10
Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter Pie: Gimme All the Peanut Butter!
Coming in at #5 on GOATED’s rankings, Axe & Sledge’s Peanut Butter Pie protein is the first—but definitely not the last—Axe & Sledge protein to make the list. Axe & Sledge is another up-and-coming company that’s been making waves with their exceptional branding and premium products. They’ve been on fire lately, and their NEW Whey More protein launch at GNC has already become wildly popular. But let’s talk about Peanut Butter Pie, because this flavor is gold. It literally tastes like the creamy, peanut buttery filling of an actual peanut butter pie. It’s smooth, sweet, and ridiculously indulgent, leaning more toward the sweet side than salty.
One of the standout aspects of this protein is its ultra-thick texture, making every sip feel sweet and satisfying. While peanut butter flavors are common in the protein world, this one is totally unique—I haven’t seen another brand nail a peanut butter pie flavor even remotely close to this. If you’re a peanut butter fan, this is another staple that deserves a spot in your rotation.
#6 MuscleSport Protella Protein
9.4/10
MuscleSport Protella: The Chocolate GOAT!
Coming in at #6 on GOATED’s all-time protein rankings with a 9.4/10, MuscleSport’s Protella. This is the second MuscleSport protein to make the list—and deservedly so. This is one of their most classic and beloved flavors; if you’re a chocolate hazelnut fan, this one’s a no-brainer. The flavor profile is simple yet flawless—a rich, Nutella-inspired protein that delivers on every level. Growing up, I was obsessed with Nutella, and this protein captures that exact experience, but in a silky smooth, high-protein format. Normally, I lean toward proteins with inclusions, but this one doesn’t even need them.
Of course, MuscleSport doesn’t just stop at mouth-watering flavors—they back it up with some of the cleanest protein sources out there. Protella is made with whey isolate and hydrolysate, two of the purest and fastest-digesting protein forms, ensuring top-notch quality. Plus, it’s packed with their fat-burning complex and digestive matrix, making it about as premium as it gets in terms of protein. ISimply put, MuscleSport’s Protella is an absolute staple.
#7 GHOST Caramel Pecan Cinnabon Protein
9.3/10
GHOST Caramel Pecan Cinnabon: Straight From the Bakery
Coming in at #7 on GOATED’s Top 10 Proteins of All Time, GHOST’s Caramel Pecan Cinnabon is another absolute masterpiece. This is the only GHOST protein to make the list, but boy, does it deserve its spot. GHOST has completely revolutionized the protein game with their authentic brand collabs, and this one is no different. They first teamed up with Cinnabon a few years back, and after the massive success of that launch, they dropped a second iteration—this time with Caramel Pecan. The flavor is rich, indulgent, and somehow... comforting. They use a whey protein isolate and concentrate blend, which provides the perfect balance of smooth texture and bold flavor, plus digestive enzymes to help with digestion.
But what really makes this protein stand out is the flavor experience it delivers. It’s warm, cozy, and outright packed with flavor, making it one of the homiest proteins to walk the face of the earth. Somehow, it manages to feel like comfort food, which is just wild for a protein powder to be able to do. The flavor is bold yet balanced, with the sweetness of caramel, the nuttiness of pecans, and the signature cinnamon roll goodness all coming together flawlessly. It genuinely feels like it was hand-crafted in a Cinnabon bakery, and if you’re a cinnamon roll lover, buckle up.
#8 Panda Sundae Cone Protein
9.3/10
Panda Sundae Cone: Literally Liquid Heaven
Coming in at #8 on GOATED’s all-time protein rankings with a 9.3/10, Panda’s Sundae Cone protein is yet another absolute banger! Over the years, Panda has cemented themselves as a powerhouse in the protein game, bringing some of the most premium formulations to the table. Like many of the proteins on this list, they don’t cut any corners. This protein packs 30g of protein per scoop, sourced from a quad-blend of whey isolate, whey concentrate, casein, and collagen. On top of that, it packs digestive enzymes for better digestion, an absorption matrix to maximize muscle growth, and Senactiv for recovery. It honestly feels criminal that their highest-ranked protein sits at #8, but this list is stacked with top-tier contenders.
As for Sundae Cone, it’s pure nostalgia in shake form. This flavor is built on a smooth, creamy vanilla ice cream base, loaded with crunchy waffle cone pieces and peanut inclusions. It’s literally a liquified sundae, and I’m not even exaggerating one bit. Panda didn’t just make a great protein—they made one of the most enjoyable flavor experiences out there.
#9 Panda S'mores Protein
9.3/10
Panda S'mores: Anotha One!
Coming in at #9 on GOATED’s all-time protein rankings with another 9.3/10, Panda’s S’mores protein proves that Panda is a force to be reckoned with. Having back-to-back proteins featured on this list is no joke. Like their Sundae Cone, this protein brings top-of-the-line quality, packing 30g of protein per serving from a premium blend of whey isolate, whey concentrate, casein, and collagen. On top of that, it’s stacked with digestive enzymes for gut health, an absorption matrix to optimize muscle growth, and Senactiv for recovery.
Now, let’s talk about the flavor and inclusions—because this is where Panda’s S’mores protein makes a name for itself. It’s built on a rich, indulgent chocolate base, but the real magic comes from the inclusions: mini marshmallows, cookie gems, and graham cracker crumbs. This combo nails the classic s’mores experience, bringing that perfect balance of chocolatey, gooey, and slightly crunchy goodness. Hands down, this is the best s’mores protein my taste buds have ever experienced.
#10 Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter N' Honey Protein
9.2/10
Axe & Sledge Peanut Butter N' Honey: The Last Man Standing
Rounding out GOATED’s Top 10 with a 9.2/10, Axe & Sledge’s Peanut Butter Honey. This is Axe & Sledge’s second protein on the list, proving that they know a thing or two about how to deliver both incredible flavor and premium quality. Unlike their Whey More formula, this one falls under their Farm Fed line, meaning it’s made with 100% whey protein isolate. That makes it lower in calories, fat, carbs, and lactose, making it a great option for those who want something easier to digest. It is a bit thinner in texture compared to their Peanut Butter Pie flavor—typical for an isolate—but what it lacks in thickness, it more than makes up for in flavor.
Speaking of flavor, this is nothing short of incredible. While I slightly prefer the texture of Peanut Butter Pie, I’d argue that this one somehow tastes even better. It starts with a silky-smooth peanut butter base and has prominently sweet notes of honey that complement the peanut butter perfectly. It instantly reminds me of the peanut butter honey biscuits I had for breakfast as a kid, so the nostalgia is real. So, if you’re looking for an ultra clean, high-quality protein, this is the only 100% whey isolate protein on this list—making it an easy pick for those who prioritize purity and digestibility.
Energy Drink, Ghost
GHOST WELCH’S GRAPE-CRAN Energy Drink Confirmed: Everything You Need to Know
GHOST WELCH’S GRAPE-CRAN Energy Drink is officially confirmed! Here’s everything you should know ahead of launch.
Read More ➡️Panda, pre-workout
Panda Supps Panta Pre-Workout Returns for the Holidays as a Budget-Friendly Fan Favorite
Panda Supps Panta Pre-Workout is back for the holidays, delivering a budget-friendly pre-workout option with solid energy and performance.
Read More ➡️Bum Energy, Energy Drink
Bum Energy Gummy Shark Flavor: NEW Gymshark Collaboration Energy Drink Revealed
Bum Energy Gummy Shark has officially launched in partnership with Gymshark, introducing a new gummy candy flavor to the energy drink market.
Read More ➡️MuscleSport, Protein Shake
Muscle Sport Un-Vaults some of its SUPERIOR Protein Powders Flavors!
MuscleSport relaunches some fan favorites! Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, Crispy Cookies, XMAS Cookie Dough & Cannoli! Nothing but perfection…
Read More ➡️Dragon Pharma, pre-workout
Dragon Venom Inferno Pre-Workout Unveils New Dragon Lychee Flavor
Dragon Venom Inferno Pre-Workout adds a new Dragon Lychee flavor to the lineup, delivering a bold twist to an intense pre-workout formula.
Read More ➡️Grenade, Protein Bars
GRENADE x CREME EGG New Protein Bar Collab!
Grenade the makers of one of the biggest protein bars in Europe, launched a new Collab is with the one and only Creme Egg!
Read More ➡️